View Proposal #224

If this proposal belongs to you, you are authorized to update it. Use the menu on the right.

ID224
First NameChristian
Last NameRoettger
InstitutionIowa State University
Speaker Categoryfaculty
Title of TalkProofs in elementary geometry - what IS the sum of angles in a triangle?
AbstractOne textbook for future teachers gives no less than four 'arguments' for this theorem. It is not claimed that they are proofs, and indeed they are not (all involve some circular reasoning). But the difference between such arguments and proofs is never made clear. We'll discover the flaws in the logic here, which are not obvious at all. Then we'll look at a number of examples from standard elementary geometry - some rock-solid one-line proofs, some examples where we all skip the proof and eyeball it, and finally an example which shows how 'eyeballing it' can lead to a 'proof' of 64=65.
Subject area(s)geometry, teacher education, proof
Suitable for undergraduates?Yes
Day Preference
Computer Needed?N
Bringing a laptop?Y
Overhead Needed?N
Software requests
Special Needs
Date Submitted3/15/2008
Year2008