| Year | First Place | Second Place | Third Place |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022 | Eric Carter(Henderson State University) | Scott Nevenhoven (Henderson State University) | Layne Grady (University of Central Oklahoma)Micah Vess (Arkansas Tech University) |
| 2021 | Luan Nguyen (Northeastern State University) | Carlos Cocoma (Northeastern State University) | Luke McLennan (Cameron University) |
| 2019 | Joshua Crouch (Southern Nazarene University) | Juan de la Cruz (University of the Ozarks) | — |
| 2018 | Vandit Trivedi (University of Tulsa) | — | — |
| 2017 | Vandit Trivedi (University of Tulsa) | Christoph Kinzel (University of Oklahoma) | Sawyer Robertson (University of Oklahoma) Jeremiah Smith (Harding University) |
| 2016 | Evan Wolfenbarger (Harding University) | Jeremiah Smith (Harding University) | Cole Brooks (Harding University) |
| 2015 | Mark Lawrence (Southern Nazarene University) | — | — |
| 2014 | Saxon Sampley (Oklahoma State University) | Travis Grigsby (Oklahoma State University) | Nina Williams (Oklahoma State University) Lindsay Lester (Southern Nazarene University) |
| 2013 | Nitesh Verma (Cameron University) | Alex Dorio (University of Central Oklahoma) | Jubal Kurudamannil (Oklahoma State University) |
| 2012 | Trang Le (University of Tulsa) | Nitesh Verma (Cameron University) | Andres Calderon (University of Central Oklahoma) |
| 2011 | Son Dang (Oklahoma University) | Tyler Eckert (University of Tulsa) Tim Bell (University of Tulsa) | Wen Shao (Northeastern State University) Tim Schlittenhardt (University of Central Oklahoma) |
| 2010 | Son Thai Dant (University of Oklahoma) | — | — |